It happens so little, I am impressed with your continued high expectations! *cough* Weeden *cough*
Well, I guess it is time for me to again defend one of my favorite college players who, like a number of other Browns quarterbacks in the past 18 years, might have had a chance to become a better than average WCO quarterback under different circumstances.
Also, like a number of other quarterbacks who have come out of the colleges in recent years, Brandon was an Air Raid quarterback before arriving in Cleveland. And like a number of other college quarterbacks with his background, he could have used some time to learn a complex NFL offense before being thrown to the wolves. A year with a clipboard watching Colt McCoy direct the offense would have given him time to learn the offense, much as I have suggested that our current rookie quarterback should spend some time as a backup before taking on a starting role.
Brandon's college experience hardly prepared him to take on a starting role in a WCO in the NFL in his rookie year. However, partly due to the perceived situation in Cleveland and partly because of his age (28 when drafted due to an earlier baseball career), Holmgren was intent upon forcing him into the starting lineup immediately. The results at the beginning of the year were not pretty. However, after the first five games,things began to improve. After losing the first five straight, we won the next five of eight games with Brandon under center. And of the three games that we lost in that series, two might have been victories with only a slight change of fortune.
In the Indianapolis game, Brandon threw a deep pass to Josh Gordon that would have given us a lead had it been caught, but as Josh was reaching for the ball, the sun suddenly shown bright through a crack in the roof and Josh dropped the ball.
And in the Dallas game, Brandon completed a touchdown pass to Benjamin Watson with a minute and ten seconds remaining in the game that gave us a three point lead, but some late game heroics by Tony Romo and a field goal by Dan Bailey tied it and we lost in overtime.
Considering the apparent improvement during those eight games, one might have expected further improvement the following year in the same system. However, by then, all things Browns had taken a radical turn. The team had been sold and at the end of the year, the people who had drafted Brandon were replaced with people who wanted their own guys. Accordingly, Brandon went from Holmgren's favored son to Banner's red-headed step-child.
Unfortunately, this was a circumstance all too familiar in Cleveland and, like others before him, it essentially ended Brandon's chance for success in Cleveland.
We will never know how things would have turned out if the team had not been sold and Holmgren & Heckert had been permitted to continue their efforts to build the team and develop Brandon as their quarterback, but it seems likely that both the team and Brandon would have shown further improvement in subsequent seasons. Considering the number of players that we sent to the Pro-Bowl the following year (2013), and considering the likely improvement that Brandon would have made with a deeper understanding of the offense, both seem likely.
What we do know is that Banner brought in a new coaching staff with a new system and in that system, Brandon regressed. He actually won the starting job at the start of the season, but he was injured in the second game and later suffered a second concussion. At the end of his second year in Cleveland--after Banner and Lombardi were fired--the new GM, Ray Farmer, released him. He is currently a backup with the Houston Texans. Considering that he is now 33 year old (34 in October) and in the last year of his current contract, this will likely be his final season. After he retires, he will likely become a college coach. He has indicated an interest in teaching the Air Raid offense at the college level.